A few years ago, a
schoolteacher of my acquaintance began talking about his personal philosophy
of teaching. He was at that time a very popular high school English teacher,
very hip and attuned to his students and well-liked by them. His personality
could be described perhaps as Mr. Chips meets Harley Davidson, a Renaissance
man “born to be wild,” comfortable riding motorcycles or quoting
Shakespeare.
“I could sum it up in four words,” he said. “Like the doctors I try my
best not to hurt anyone, yeah, ‘First, do no harm” is the way I believe
about teaching kids.” He went on to explain that he had come to this
philosophy through years of experience listening and interacting with
children. He said that he realized that each child was very different in
their aptitudes and needs and did not always fit nicely into a standardized
curriculum intent on cultural homogenization. Forcing Shakespeare down the
craw of a teenager who is something of a mechanical genius, for example,
probably enlightens neither Shakespeare nor the youth.
I must agree. In her never-ending attempts to force learning down my
throat, my fourth grade teacher stood me in front of the class and on three
occasions tore up my spelling homework in front of my classmates. She was
successful, but for years afterward, I cringed inside whenever the scenes
rose up out of the cesspool of my suppressed memories and replayed in my
mind.
However, I never made overly simple sentences with spelling words ever
again; such “babyish” sentences (as she called them) as “the quantity is
many” or “the paper is white.” To this day, I am a little scared of the
short, simple sentence and must check a tendency to pile on phrases and
clauses to be sure that I “have enough words in the sentence.”
Primum non nocere or “First, do no harm” is identified
with
the Hippocratic oath that medical doctors take. The phrase is not actually
part of the oath but is in some other writings of the great Greek physician.
(The oath does refer to "refraining from deleterious and mischievous
actions."). Hippocrates, the father of modern medicine, also spoke Greek
rather than Latin. You can read a translation of the oath
here.
In my own life, I see its wisdom from the attitudes toward the earth
expressed in organic farming. I related in my article,
Organic Touchstone, the importance that I felt of a holistic
relationship with human beings and the earth. With organic farming, I see
that I am expressing the virtue of doing no harm when I do not overburden
and poison the soil with pesticides, insecticides and artificial
fertilizers. Working with the soil, I use natural methods of composting and
pest control.
Self-righteousness is the great enemy of the philosophy of "no harm."
Yet, it is so easy to believe that you have the proper solution to whatever
ails self or others. The old saying that "pride goeth before a fall" is
certainly evident here. Here, just read this book, study the works of this
spiritual master, try some counseling, or just take a walk.
How easy it is to feel as if you have the answers; how easy to force them
onto someone else not knowing the life experience of that human being, not
knowing if you are only making things worse as you "prescribe" your remedy.
Sometimes, only God knows what that person needs. The rest of us need to
stand off a bit, maybe observe closely for a while and take action—if
needed—rather gently and with a whole lot of respect and humility for the
person or situation.
I decided to research this truism on the Web. One of the first sites that
I came across is one actually entitled
First Do No Harm, a site that offers “An Alternative Approach For
Assisting Clients With Weight Related Concerns.” This site, targeted for
health professionals, examines, among other ideas, how the thin, body image
perpetuated by the media affects the lives of Americans, particularly women.
The idea here is that not everyone is capable of achieving the slender
cultural ideal with which the media bombards us day and night promoting
anorexic-looking models and movie stars. While we can achieve a healthy
weight, we may not necessarily resemble Meg Ryan or Russell Crow. To insist
upon this ideal is to do great harm to those with body image issues.
There is actually a movie called, First, Do No Harm starring Meryl
Streep. In an
interview Ms. Streep talks about her character, a mother who discovered
just prior to brain surgery on her epileptic child that medical authorities
were not telling her about a special "ketogenic" diet that was often very
effective in reducing seizures in epileptic children. The rule of doing no
harm was not followed because though most doctors knew of the diet, it was
not emphasized as a treatment in most medical schools. Switching the child
to this diet produced a veritable miracle in seizure reduction and surgery
was aborted. First, do no harm!
The ethical dilemma sometimes posed by the "no harm" attitude is seen in
the debate over circumcision of infants. My personal feeling is that the
freedom and dignity of the child supersedes the prerogatives of religious
tradition. To me, cutting a boy's foreskin without his awareness and
permission is a prime example of doing harm while meaning well by blindly
following cultural practices from another era. This subject of male infant
circumcision is explored philosophically but with great understanding at
Primum Non Nocere.
First, Do No Harm is good advice from a great healer in an ancient
time. Anytime a person or a philosophy is still "alive and kicking" after a
few millennium or so, I cannot help but feel that perhaps I should take it
seriously. I find this philosophical perception more than just another adage
expressed with pretty words in a clever verbal pattern.
Primum Non Nocere: To act only as necessary but always with
humility and courage and compassion.
Copyright 2002, Thomas James Martin, all rights reserved.